Thoughts on Vandana Shiva's India Divided: Diversity and Democracy Under Attack

I found Vandana Shiva’s opening stress on the historical diversity of India wonderfully helpful, particularly her quick historical overview of how the term “Hindu” has morphed from designating a geographical area of diverse populations into a religious and nationalist designation (and the role the British played in the transformation of this term). This puts the contemporary struggle between, in particular, Hindus and Muslims in a helpful historical perspective.
Read more

Thoughts on Ashis Nandy's book, The Intimate Enemy

This is an intriguing and challenging work of postcolonial criticism, although Nandy doesn’t really invoke the term “postcolonial” (see below) and, indeed, has some scathing things to say about postcolonial criticism in the West (criticism he sees as elitist, critics who are in his view “ornamental dissenters” [p. 10] though he doesn’t name names). His focus on the psychology of colonialism is what sets this book apart and what I found most engaging about it. I think it begs the question of what relation there is, however, between the psychology and the politics of colonialism. It seems to me they’re intimately linked and the book could have stressed this more, i.e. the politics of colonialism produces a range of psychologies that feed back into political behavior, so the relation between the two is a little more symmetrical than he suggests. But all of this is implied and the value of the book is how it gets you to think about the relationship between the two.

Read more

"Why Terror"

I've posted the imaginary exchange between Osama Bin Laden and Mahatma Gandhi that we've been asked to read. You can access it here.

Postmodern Gandhi and Other Essays

I'm going to start posting some of my musings about the texts we're reading for our trip. Click here for some thoughts on the essays in Postmodern Gandhi.